A Radical Budget Compromise Plan

Is there any hope of bringing Republicans and Democrats together to tackle the tough fiscal problems that the US faces?  Believe it or not, I think there is!

The Heritage Blog produced a great info graphic comparing the recent budget plans from the House and the Senate:


It’s obvious these two plans are so far apart that neither has any hope of clearing both houses of Congress and if we had a President who was interesting in solving our problems, he’d call them together to reach a compromise.  But we know that won’t happen…….But I think there is a chance for a compromise that would be very meaningful for our country.

But before I get to that, let’s go over a few givens that most people would accept as facts:

1)      Obama and the Democrats have a desire to increase tax revenues via raising income taxes on the wealthy.

2)      A vast majority of people who voted for Obama and continue to support Democratic candidates are big supporters of raising taxes on the wealthy.

3)      Democrats believe that through higher taxes on the wealthy, the poor will have more money (i.e. handouts) from the government and their wealth will rise.

4)      Obamacare is going to wreck our healthcare industry and this 20,000 page regulation nightmare will cause less people to receive needed care.

5)      Obamacare will end up costing our Federal Government way more that was first estimated.

6)      Obamacare will end up costing American citizens way more than was first estimated.

Given those knows facts, I have a radical compromise plan.

The Republicans in the House and Senate should agree to pass legislation that raises income tax rate (to levels set forth by the Democrats) on those making over $400,000 if (and only if) Obama and the Democrats in the House and Senate agree to repeal Obamacare.

What?  Have you lost your mind?  Raising taxes on the wealthy will be harmful for the economy and won’t raise tax revenue as history has shown us.  Yes I know that.

Obama would never repeal his signature achievement of his presidency, not even for higher taxes on the wealthy!  Yes I know that too.

Both of those critiques are true but think of the messaging opportunity this would give the Republicans.

Leftists scream about income inequality and in a sense that is why people like Massachusetts’ Elizabeth Warren got elected to the US Senate.  Leftists have a soft spot for taxing the rich and they’ll thrown logic out the window if they have a chance to close the deal on higher tax rates for the evil 1%.  Once they think this is a possibility, they’ll be like sharks swimming in a pool of blood – they’ll ignore everything else to accomplish this one overriding goal!  And you can count on them applying the heat to Obama and Reid to get it done.

Republicans can easily point to all the harm that Obamacare is already causing and then say we need to repeal it and then address healthcare reform piecemeal instead of a grand plan that was hopelessly flawed.  It can be sold as a win for the Democrats because they are abandoning a program that isn’t even implemented yet in favor of immediate tax rate increases on the wealthy.  The Democratic base will think they’ll be getting instant handouts while abandoning future promises of better healthcare that more than likely wouldn’t have materialized in the first place.

Obama and the Democrats would be forced to defend Obamacare over the holy grail of Leftists ideology – taxing the rich.  I don’t think they can do it.

For a few years we’d suffer under the high income tax rates on the wealthy but at least we’d be spared the evils of Obamacare and once we win the White House in 2016 and hopefully take control of the Senate as well, then we can come to the country’s rescue and show how these higher income tax rates didn’t really translate into more tax revenue.  Of course we’d repeal those tax rates and return them to 2012 levels….for the good of the country.

What do you think?  Am I crazy?

This entry was posted in economics, healthcare, Over Regulation, politics. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to A Radical Budget Compromise Plan

  1. blaine says:


    Yes, you’re crazy. There is no way Obama will ever sign legislation repealing his signature legislation. The chance of this ever happening is less than zero.

    What’s really fascinating is guys like Bill Maher stating California could lose him as a resident because of high taxes. This from a guy who gave a million dollars to the Obama Campaign.


    The old saying that the definition of a conservative: “a liberal who has been mugged,” may be at play here.

    There is no question that Obamacare will cost more than projected and deliver far less. There will be rationing for the simple reason there are not enough primary care physicians to deliver primary care to everyone with insurance.

    So the good news is everyone will be insured, the bad news is there will be a two tiered healthcare system. People who can pay extra will have access to good medical care. The poor will wait in line and get poor service and because they are now insured, they will flood emergency rooms and urgent care centers even more than what is happening now. Their “doctors” will be Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants in Cuba style clinics.

    Since the government and insurance companies will continue to mandate performance levels and limit payments to doctors and hospitals and then impose penalties for not reaching arbitrary goals, doctors will retire early and hospitals will go out of business thus reducing the supply even more.

    This is not dissimilar to when the commissars in the old Soviet Union set national wheat production goals and the price of wheat without any consideration as to whether the farmers could actually achieve the goals or grow the wheat for less than the price paid for it.

    Cooperative farms continued to perform miserably and wheat production steadily declined at the same time farm production skyrocketed from the limited number of private plots farmers were allowed to keep the earning from.

    PS: According to the CIA World Factbook, Cuba has twice the number of doctors per capita then the US and twice the number of hospital beds at the same time Cuba spends a third less of it’s GDP on healthcare. A workers paradise!

    Wonder how that worked out for Hugo? Most dictators still prefer doctors from the Mayo Clinic and Johns Hopkins

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s